A demand for forfeiture can change the financial stakes of a customary divorce considerably. One spouse may argue that the other should leave the marriage with less than the patrimonial benefit that would ordinarily follow from the applicable matrimonial property regime.
This does not mean a spouse can simply demand all the assets because the marriage was short, because one person earned more, or because serious misconduct is alleged.
Forfeiture in a customary divorce requires a court to consider a specific statutory test. Before reaching that test, the applicable matrimonial property regime and the patrimonial benefit in question must be identified. The outcome depends on the marriage, the property consequences and the evidence placed before the court.
The statutory starting point is section 8(4)(a) of the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998, read with section 9 of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979.
For a broader explanation of how customary marriages are dissolved, read our guide to divorce from a customary marriage. That article considers validity, proof and the general divorce process. This article focuses on the narrower financial question of forfeiture.
Forfeiture in a Customary Divorce: What Does It Mean?
Forfeiture in a customary divorce concerns a patrimonial benefit that a spouse would otherwise receive because of the marriage and its applicable property regime.
The court must identify that benefit before deciding whether it should be forfeited wholly or partly. A forfeiture order is not a general power to confiscate everything a spouse owns. It is distinct from redistribution, spousal maintenance and the ordinary division of matrimonial property.
The starting question is what the spouse would receive if the ordinary consequences of the matrimonial property regime applied. The court can then consider whether retaining that benefit would result in an undue benefit in relation to the other spouse.
The applicable property regime is therefore central to any claim for forfeiture in a customary marriage.
If a forfeiture claim may materially affect your property position, contact Vermeulen Attorneys for advice on the applicable property regime and the benefit that may be in dispute.
Establish the Customary Marriage and Property Regime First
When considering forfeiture in a customary divorce, the marriage and its proprietary consequences must first be established. This determines the patrimonial benefits on divorce that may be relevant to the forfeiture enquiry.
Relevant questions may include:
- When was the customary marriage concluded?
- Is the marriage monogamous or polygynous?
- Was it concluded before or after the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act came into operation?
- Is there an antenuptial contract?
- Is there a court-approved contract relating to a further customary marriage?
- Are there other spouses whose proprietary rights may be affected?
- Which assets fall within the relevant matrimonial property structure?
For a monogamous customary marriage concluded after the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act came into operation, section 7 regulates the proprietary consequences. More complex considerations may arise in pre-Act and polygynous customary marriages.
The Recognition of Customary Marriages Amendment Act 1 of 2021 also changed the statutory treatment of proprietary rights in certain customary marriages concluded before the principal Act came into operation.
The legal and factual investigation should therefore take place before either spouse assumes what they are supposed to receive.
Registration of ownership on a title deed is relevant evidence, although it may not determine the entire enquiry. The marriage date, structure of the marriage, applicable statutory provisions, matrimonial agreements, court orders and classification of individual assets may all require consideration.
How Does the Undue-Benefit Test Work?
In forfeiture in a customary divorce, section 8(4)(a) of the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act makes specified provisions of the Divorce Act applicable when a court grants a decree for dissolution. This includes the court’s power to make a forfeiture order under section 9 of the Divorce Act.
Under section 9 of the Divorce Act, the court considers whether one spouse would be unduly benefited in relation to the other if forfeiture were not ordered.
The court considers three statutory factors:
- The duration of the marriage.
- The circumstances that gave rise to the breakdown of the marriage.
- Any substantial misconduct by either spouse.
The enquiry depends on the facts. A short marriage can be relevant, although its duration does not determine the outcome on its own.
Serious misconduct can also be relevant. The enquiry remains whether the identified patrimonial benefit would be undue in the particular circumstances.
An undue benefit in divorce cannot ordinarily be established by a broad allegation that one spouse deserves nothing. The evidence must be connected to the actual proprietary consequences of the marriage.
Is Misconduct Enough to Lose a Share?
When forfeiture in a customary divorce is sought on the basis of misconduct, no single allegation should be treated as an automatic basis for forfeiture.
Adultery is a common example. A spouse may regard adultery as the cause of the breakdown and may want that conduct reflected in the financial outcome. Adultery on its own does not answer the statutory question.
The same caution applies to abandonment. Evidence of prolonged absence or conduct contributing to the breakdown may be relevant, but the court must still assess that conduct as part of the wider undue-benefit enquiry.
Differences in financial contribution also require careful treatment. A spouse who earned little or no salary may have made substantial non-financial contributions through childcare, household responsibilities, support for a family business or other work that benefited the family.
A claim for forfeiture in a customary marriage should therefore be based on evidence and the proprietary consequences of the marriage rather than a moral conclusion about which spouse caused the relationship to end.
If substantial misconduct is being relied upon for or against forfeiture, obtain legal advice before assuming that the allegation determines the financial outcome. Contact Vermeulen Attorneys to discuss how the evidence may relate to the statutory test.
What Evidence Can Support or Defeat a Forfeiture Claim?
Evidence is central to forfeiture in a customary divorce. A spouse seeking or opposing forfeiture should begin collecting relevant documents early.
Documents concerning the marriage and property may include:
- The marriage certificate.
- Documents showing when the customary marriage was concluded.
- Lobolo records.
- An antenuptial contract, where applicable.
- Any court-approved contract regulating the matrimonial property system.
- Title deeds.
- Bank and mortgage statements.
- Payslips and business records.
- Vehicle registration documents.
- Purchase agreements.
- Invoices relating to property or substantial improvements.
- Relevant financial disclosures.
The evidence required to prove alleged misconduct depends on the allegation. Relevant material may include communications, photographs, admissions, witness testimony and financial records showing the movement or diversion of matrimonial funds.
A spouse opposing forfeiture should also document financial and non-financial contributions. Evidence of childcare, household management, support for a family business and other contributions may be important where the other spouse relies heavily on differences in direct financial contribution.
Most importantly, the evidence should establish the patrimonial benefits on divorce that are actually disputed. The court cannot properly conduct the forfeiture enquiry if the alleged benefit remains vague.
Polygynous Customary Marriages Require Additional Care
Forfeiture in a customary divorce can require additional analysis where more than one customary marriage is involved because the proprietary rights of other spouses may also be relevant.
The date of each marriage matters. The applicable version of section 7 of the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, the structure of the marriages, existing court orders and any contract regulating the matrimonial property system may also require consideration.
Where a further customary marriage is concluded after the Act came into operation, section 7 contains provisions dealing with a court-approved written contract regulating the future matrimonial property system of the marriages. The proprietary rights of existing and prospective spouses may therefore become relevant.
A forfeiture claim should not be framed as a general attempt to redistribute a wider family estate. The affected property, the relevant marriage and the legal rights of each spouse must be identified.
Where another spouse has a direct and substantial interest in the property or relief sought, joinder may need to be considered. An order affecting proprietary rights should take account of legally protected interests beyond the two parties to the divorce.
If the marriage is polygynous or another spouse may have an interest in the affected assets, speak to Vermeulen Attorneys before finalising a property settlement or proposed order.
How Should a Forfeiture Claim Be Pleaded?
A claim for forfeiture in a customary divorce should be expressly addressed in the pleadings.
The claim should identify:
- The applicable matrimonial property regime.
- The patrimonial benefit the other spouse would otherwise receive.
- The material facts establishing that benefit.
- The approximate value of the benefit, where it can reasonably be established.
- The duration of the marriage.
- The circumstances relied upon regarding the breakdown of the marriage.
- Any substantial misconduct relied upon.
- Why retaining the identified benefit is alleged to be undue.
- Whether total or partial forfeiture is sought.
A vague request that the other spouse forfeit all benefits can obscure the real dispute.
The same precision is required when the parties settle the matter. The settlement agreement and proposed divorce order should identify the affected assets and explain what must happen to them.
Where relevant, the documents should address ownership, occupation, transfer requirements, mortgage liabilities, division of sale proceeds and implementation dates. Where other spouses or households have proprietary interests, those interests should also be considered before the settlement is finalised.
Forfeiture Is Different From Maintenance and Redistribution
A claim for forfeiture in a customary divorce should not be used as shorthand for every financial issue arising when the marriage ends.
Spousal maintenance involves considerations that differ from the statutory forfeiture enquiry. Redistribution, where legally available, is also a separate form of relief with its own requirements.
Pension-related relief must be considered independently. The existence of a pension interest does not remove the need to establish the correct matrimonial property consequences and formulate the appropriate relief.
More than one financial remedy may arise in the same divorce. Each should be identified and dealt with on its own legal basis.
What Should You Do if Forfeiture Is Being Claimed?
If forfeiture in a customary divorce is being claimed against you, do not assume that you will lose everything simply because this has been asserted in correspondence, negotiations or family discussions.
Equally, a spouse seeking forfeiture should not assume that serious misconduct is sufficient on its own.
Legal advice should first address four issues:
- Whether the customary marriage is legally established.
- Which matrimonial property regime applies.
- What patrimonial benefit will arise if forfeiture is not ordered.
- What evidence supports or defeats the allegation that the benefit would be undue.
This assessment can materially affect the pleadings and the approach taken during settlement negotiations.
If a forfeiture dispute is likely, identifying the relevant property and documentary evidence early may prevent the case from developing into an unfocused dispute about the parties’ entire financial history.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does forfeiture in a customary divorce work?
Forfeiture in a customary divorce involves identifying a patrimonial benefit that one spouse would ordinarily receive and considering whether retaining that benefit would unduly benefit that spouse in relation to the other. The court applies the statutory factors and considers the evidence in the particular case.
Can I lose my share because I committed adultery?
Adultery does not determine a forfeiture claim on its own. The circumstances leading to the breakdown and any substantial misconduct may be relevant, but the court must still consider the patrimonial consequences and whether there would be an undue benefit in divorce if forfeiture were not ordered.
Does a short marriage justify forfeiture?
The duration of the marriage is one of the statutory considerations. A short marriage can therefore be relevant to forfeiture in a customary divorce, but duration must be considered as part of the wider statutory enquiry.
Can my spouse claim all the assets?
A demand for all the assets does not determine the legal outcome. The applicable matrimonial property regime must first be established and the alleged benefit identified. A forfeiture order concerns an identifiable patrimonial benefit arising from the marriage.
Does failing to earn an income mean I contributed nothing?
No. Financial contribution is not the only relevant form of contribution. Childcare, household responsibilities, assistance in a family business and other non-financial contributions may form part of the evidence.
What does section 9 of the Divorce Act provide?
Section 9 of the Divorce Act provides the statutory framework for the forfeiture of patrimonial benefits. In a customary divorce, the relevant court power applies through section 8(4)(a) of the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act.
Can forfeiture affect another wife in a polygynous marriage?
An order should not disregard another wife’s independent proprietary rights. Where another spouse has a direct and substantial interest in the property or relief sought, questions concerning joinder and the scope of the proposed order may arise.
Speak to Vermeulen Attorneys About a Forfeiture Dispute
Claims involving forfeiture in a customary divorce can become complicated because the court cannot assess forfeiture properly without understanding the marriage, property regime, affected assets and available evidence.
This is especially relevant in polygynous marriages or where substantial property, businesses, pension interests or competing proprietary rights are involved.
Vermeulen Attorneys can assess the applicable matrimonial property regime, the patrimonial benefit in dispute, the available evidence and the relief that may need to be pleaded. Contact Vermeulen Attorneys to arrange a consultation before a settlement is signed or the matter proceeds further.